PDA

View Full Version : In our view: Security Is crucial (on Loot Rail)


Chief
06-15-2008, 06:04 AM
http://www.columbian.com/opinion/news/2008/06/06152008_In-our-view-Security-Is-crucial.cfm

Sunday, June 15, 2008

The assault of a Vancouver woman when she was riding the MAX light-rail in North Portland last week has again illustrated the need for aggressive security on the trains and on the platforms, as well as for vigilant ticket-checking to discourage no-pay riders.

The incident is also a public relations blow to TriMet and its trains at a time gas prices are prompting more commuters to consider mass transit. And, it likely will reinforce negative feelings among those in Clark County who oppose extension of light rail into Vancouver on a new Interstate 5 bridge.

Safety of riders on any mass transit system is a legitimate concern. TriMet has made strides in beefing up security in recent months, and there’s more it can do. But some perspective also is in order.

First, there’s concern about crime and safety just about everywhere: high school football games, outdoor concerts, highways where road-ragers roam, strip malls and convenience stores. And it’s almost summer, so let’s not overlook campgrounds occupied by loudmouths more interested in beer than trees, trails and mountains. To some degree all of these venues are only reflections of society as a whole.

Second, there are more riders these days, and thus greater chances for uncivil conduct. In May, TriMet trains and buses provided 8.9 million rides, an increase of 4.4 percent over May 2007. The weekday average for light-rail alone in May was 112,100.

On Monday, the 28-year-old Vancouver woman was riding MAX for the first time, according to The Oregonian, when she attempted to intercede on behalf of another woman rider who was being harassed by five African-American teenagers. As the train continued along North Interstate Avenue, the teens shouted racial insults at the Vancouver woman, who is white, and punched her. When the train stopped at Prescott Street, the teens grabbed her purse and fled.

“It was completely traumatizing and absolutely horrifying for me,” the victim told The Oregonian.

The good news is that security cameras at the platform recorded the young hoodlums as they ran away. By Friday, all five suspects had been arrested.

This was the fifth violent incident since November on or near the trains, two in Gresham, one near Beaverton and two in North Portland. Since last fall, TriMet has beefed up security. According to spokeswoman Mary Fetsch, at this time last year TriMet had about 25 uniformed, gun-carrying commissioned police on its payroll. Today it has 41, and two more are to be hired by July 1. TriMet recently authorized 50 supervisors to check riders for tickets, augmenting the force of 18 regular fare inspectors.

On the other hand, the uniformed private Wackenhutt security people visible at many TriMet stations are relatively toothless. They don’t carry weapons and do not have arrest powers. Nor are they expected to physically break up a fight. If they spot trouble, they’re to call 911.

TriMet must continue enhancing its security operation.

Chief
06-15-2008, 06:07 AM
yah, so we just need to keep things in perspective and realize that it could be a lot worse.

Someone please tell me what authority Trimet has in Washington State??

Shouldn't the discussion be about how much it will cost C-Tran to provide enhanced security right off the bat if Vancouver's Loot Rail System ever gets built??

Law enforcement and crime prevention are major hidden expenses of every transit system...

More food for thought...

cewl

Waterbuffalo
06-15-2008, 07:49 PM
Wile riding the Maxx on both the Yellow and Red lines over the past six months regularly to go see friends or family in Portland, here is what I have observed.

Very little security or transit police on patrol on the Maxx trains until the day after this incident. There are a lot of cameras on the stations, buses and trains but do they deter the crime?

As you have seen in the video from the news media over the past couple of days, this only shows you the deterrent factor is the video cameras are catching the perpetrators with events-in-motion but it only gives these kids and adults a slap on the wrist when they actually get nailed for some thing.

How many times have I rode the Maxx into downtown Portland and seen loads of kids off the Red Maxx line get off at Lloyd Center or kids riding to Downtown Portland on the Yellow line because the place to hang out is in downtown and not for positive reasons.

Yeah, Portland does homeless sweeps to clear out the bums and street walkers before Rose Festival and clear the trains if they have to but has security been "enhanced" right after something happens just to curry favor with decision makers and the general populace , than three to six months later, pull all the over time or transit police off buses and trains because of budgetary concerns..

It seems every time an incident happens, three or six months later, there is another one of these beat downs, drug deals, shootings or other major problems.

Look I can understand the Tri-met is not perfect and cannot prevent all crimes from happen on any of its multitude of transit systems. But should be able to expect that some form of regular transit oriented police officers will be patrolling the Maxx system and be visible to our general populace instead of relying on private security guards with radios who basically sitting targets to any criminal who decides they do not want to leave evidence or witnesses to a crime being committed.

There have been promises, assurances and lots of comment over the past twenty years from Tri-met but has the quasi-regional government transit agency ever been held to account for the continual blunder and mistakes?

Has a high level manager or Tri-met official ever been fired for actions by itself or members of an oversight committee for these continual blunders and lives ruined because this transit agencies lacks foresight, planning and actions that state to the public it means business?

When its convenient, they seem to have all the money in the world to bring out and pay for lavish or useless items or put transit cops and other vitally needed protections in place year round to prevent this nonsense from continually happening?

Why are there not turnstiles at all of the Maxx stations to prevent non-paying people coming on to the platforms?

Why is there not more enforcement of the rules on Maxx to prevent these blunders and side shows?

Where is the plan of both maxx and buses to prevent this from happening in the future?

To the Tri-met and C-tran officials, we're watching how your responding to the last two weeks and plans to implement some serious security. This, "I can do X" and depending mostly on events-on-tape CCTV is not going to cut it any more. All that does is just records the perpetrators and may just get them slapped into juvenile hall until age 21 and out they go.

Every county from Clackamas to Clark to Washington, Yamhill, Multnomah and its citizens are watching you. Pretty soon you will have a foothold over in Clark County and honestly, this game playing your doing is *NOT* going to cut it here.

Go out and invest seriously in what needs to be done. IF you expect that the citizens of Clark County are going to willingly to tax us, allow people to come into our community over any type of transit system and commit heinous or minimal crimes in City of Vancouver or Clark County, your sadly mistaken that we'll allow you to continue access to this area and dump your uncontrolled growth and easy political consequences without some public repercussions...